Used Tesla Model Y for Sale in Tustin, CA
Only 58 of the 288 used Tesla Model Ys for sale in Orange County qualify as Bestest, and 57 of them are within 15 miles of Tustin, with listing prices from $29,867 to $44,117 as of November 21, 2026. We’ve already screened out the problematic models, second-tier dealers and cars over 50,000 miles, leaving just the used cars we’d recommend to friends and family.
1378

2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
35,478
mi
$36,717
·
35,478
miles ·
Autonation Ford Tustin
,
Tustin
Autonation Ford Tustin
$36,717
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2024 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
31,784
mi
$37,942
·
31,784
miles ·
Nissan of Tustin
,
Tustin
Nissan of Tustin
$37,942
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2021 Tesla Model Y
Standard Range
•
47,205
mi
$29,867
·
47,205
miles ·
Nissan of Tustin
,
Tustin
Nissan of Tustin
$29,867
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2023 Tesla Model Y
Performance
•
19,546
mi
$42,621
·
19,546
miles ·
Tustin Lexus
,
Tustin
Tustin Lexus
$42,621
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
24,912
mi
$41,100
·
24,912
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$41,100
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
20,164
mi
$42,400
·
20,164
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$42,400
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
27,744
mi
$37,600
·
27,744
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$37,600
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
35,125
mi
$39,600
·
35,125
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$39,600
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2024 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
21,728
mi
$43,100
·
21,728
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$43,100
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Base
•
16,968
mi
$37,200
·
16,968
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$37,200
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
18,338
mi
$41,000
·
18,338
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$41,000
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Performance
•
41,732
mi
$39,600
·
41,732
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$39,600
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
32,713
mi
$38,200
·
32,713
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$38,200
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
38,837
mi
$35,500
·
38,837
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$35,500
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
18,254
mi
$37,700
·
18,254
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$37,700
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
41,897
mi
$35,100
·
41,897
miles ·
Tesla Irvine
,
Irvine
Tesla Irvine
$35,100
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2024 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
31,213
mi
$44,117
·
31,213
miles ·
Toyota of Orange
,
Orange
Toyota of Orange
$44,117
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2023 Tesla Model Y
Base
•
29,896
mi
$33,575
·
29,896
miles ·
Anaheim Hyundai
,
Anaheim
Anaheim Hyundai
$33,575
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2024 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
11,091
mi
$41,612
·
11,091
miles ·
Nissan of Costa Mesa
,
Costa Mesa
Nissan of Costa Mesa
$41,612
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
31,093
mi
$37,640
·
31,093
miles ·
Nissan of Costa Mesa
,
Costa Mesa
Nissan of Costa Mesa
$37,640
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
39,562
mi
$35,982
·
39,562
miles ·
Nissan of Costa Mesa
,
Costa Mesa
Nissan of Costa Mesa
$35,982
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2024 Tesla Model Y
Performance
•
13,324
mi
$42,573
·
13,324
miles ·
Nissan of Costa Mesa
,
Costa Mesa
Nissan of Costa Mesa
$42,573
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2023 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
24,505
mi
$37,402
·
24,505
miles ·
Nissan of Costa Mesa
,
Costa Mesa
Nissan of Costa Mesa
$37,402
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing

2024 Tesla Model Y
Long Range
•
15,558
mi
$43,112
·
15,558
miles ·
Nissan of Costa Mesa
,
Costa Mesa
Nissan of Costa Mesa
$43,112
See listing
Recommended ✅ Model ✅ Dealer ✅ Listing
